How to compare technician pay schemes
Revenue is jobs times the average ticket. A percent scheme pays that revenue times the percent. Base plus bonus pays a fixed amount plus a percent of revenue. Hourly pays hours times the hourly rate. Divide each pay by revenue and you see what share of every sale goes to wages.
In the example revenue is $6,000, and the three schemes cost $1,800, $1,600 and $1,280.
What each scheme is made of
- Percent: 30% of revenue, so pay moves with every sale.
- Base plus bonus: $1,000 fixed plus 10% of revenue.
- Hourly: 160 hours at $8, the same pay in a slow month.
- Share of revenue: pay divided by revenue, so you can compare the schemes on one scale.
What decides which scheme fits
- How steady your work is. Hourly pay is a risk on slow weeks.
- How much of the ticket is materials, since a percent of revenue also pays on parts.
- Whether you want technicians to hurry or to do quality work.
- Payroll taxes, which sit on top of any scheme.
Pay scheme mistakes
The result is an estimate from the numbers you enter, not advice on what to pay.
- Paying a percent of revenue without looking at material cost.
- Leaving payroll taxes out of the comparison.
- Comparing schemes at different workloads.
- Changing the scheme without telling the crew how it works.